Skip to content

The Difference Between Biblical and Social Justice

By Dr. Christina Crenshaw, Guest Blogger

There is a strange phenomenon emerging in Western culture. A growing number of non-Christian thought leaders are publicly admitting they like the fruit of Christianity. The problem is that they don’t want to believe in the tree.

For example, psychologist Jordan Peterson knows Christian theology arguably as well as many pastors, yet he does not claim to follow Christ. Podcaster Joe Rogan, social psychologist Jonathan Haidt, and historian Tom Holland have each expressed appreciation for Christianity’s cultural benefits without professing faith. Most striking of all was Richard Dawkins, the famous atheist behind The God Delusion. In a 2024 radio interview, Dawkins called himself a “cultural Christian.” He said he enjoys hymns and Christmas carols and feels at home in the Christian ethos.

The Root and the Fruit

Claiming to love the fruit of Christianity while denying Christ is a bit like claiming to love the taste of pears while insisting there is no such thing as a pear tree. Christians know better. We know we cannot reap the fruit of Christianity without roots planted deeply in Christ; we cannot have a Christian culture without Christ.

In classical Greek thought, the good, the true, and the beautiful are ultimate ideals. But they are ideals rooted in humanism. In Christianity, God is absolute Goodness, absolute Truth, and absolute Beauty. Anything good, true, or beautiful in the world not only reflects God, but it is also derived from Him. Christianity teaches that these concepts became tangible in Jesus Christ. Jesus explicitly calls Himself “the way, and the truth, and the life” (John 14:6) and “the good shepherd” (John 10:11). The Apostle Paul echoes this triad in Philippians 4:8, instructing believers to focus their minds on whatever is true, honorable, just, pure, lovely (beautiful), and commendable (good).

And we can see the fruit of Christianity. These benefits flourished from centuries of Christian belief and practice. The dignity of every person, care for the sick and poor, the call to forgive our enemies: all of it grew from the conviction that God became man and that every human being bears His image. As the French philosopher Rémi Brague has put it, we owe European civilization “to people who believed in Christ,” not to people who merely believed in Christianity. We cannot divorce the values from the beliefs.

I’ll admit that when cultural elites concede Christianity’s goodness, part of me wants to say, “We told you so.” But if we exchange hubris for humility, we will see this moment for what it is: an open door. People who appreciate the fruit are already curious about the tree. That gives us an opportunity to explain why Christianity matters far beyond tradition and culture. Our values come from Christ. He is the source of the fruit.

Why We Long for Justice

And the fruit of Christ produces far more than cathedrals and carols. Jesus embodies a radical vision of forgiveness, compassion and justice, all flowing from a relationship with Him.

Our longing for justice is itself evidence that the world is not as it should be. We recoil at racism, oppression and abuse because God’s law is written on our hearts (Romans 2:15), even when our eyes are blinded by cultural narratives, misguided leaders or the Enemy himself, who comes “to steal and kill and destroy” (John 10:10).

That is why it matters that Christians name Christ as the reason for the good we do. Doing justice is not simply humanitarian work. It is spiritual battle. Each time we bring light to darkness, living water to the thirsty and the bread of life to the hungry, the Enemy loses ground and the gospel advances.

The Church, Not the State

Christians should absolutely use their influence for good in every sphere of society, including government. But leading the work of justice is ultimately the Church’s calling, not the state’s. When we place our hope in governments to save us, disappointment is inevitable. History offers sobering examples of movements that promised a just society and delivered tyranny instead. The more power we hand the state to enforce its vision of justice, the greater the risk of new forms of oppression.

Partnership with the public sector is appropriate and often necessary. Church and state can and should work together for the common good. But partnering with government is very different from placing our hope in it. Our hope rests in Christ alone.

Justice Rooted in the Cross

Why does a biblical view of justice matter? Because Christian justice is rooted in the cross. In Christ’s death, God’s perfect justice and perfect love meet. Sin is condemned in full, and yet mercy triumphs because Jesus bears that penalty on our behalf. God is both “just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus” (Romans 3:26).

Biblical justice, then, is both accountability and grace. It does not excuse evil, and it does not abandon sinners. That is the kind of justice the world longs for and cannot produce on its own.

As followers of Christ, may we be marked by a zeal for justice in all its forms because of our hope in Him. We speak up for the marginalized, the oppressed and the forgotten. We labor to build systems that reflect God’s heart for human flourishing. We pray, work, advocate and serve, not because the world tells us to, but because every act of compassion is a foretaste of God’s coming kingdom.

Where Justice Begins: Your Own Front Door

How might God be inviting your family into His redemptive plan? Biblical justice is not reserved for churches and nonprofits. It begins in everyday moments where Christ’s love meets human need:

  • Bring a meal to a new mother or to a family walking through illness or grief.
  • Offer rides to an elderly neighbor who can no longer drive to church, the grocery store or the doctor.
  • Mentor a child from a single-parent home, or simply make room for one more at your dinner table.
  • Redirect resources toward ministries that address injustice from a biblical worldview, and let your children help choose where the family gives.
  • Volunteer your professional skills at a pregnancy resource center, a refugee ministry or an anti-trafficking organization.
  • Share the gospel in word and deed. Acts of mercy open doors, but only the good news of Jesus transforms hearts.

Children learn what justice looks like by watching us practice it. When our kids see us show up for a neighbor, give generously and explain that we do it because Jesus first loved us (1 John 4:19), they learn that faith is not just something we believe. It is something we live.

Each act of justice, however small, bears witness to the coming kingdom where all things will be made right.

Hope Has the Final Word

Secular social justice often focuses on restructuring power and achieving equal outcomes. Biblical justice is rooted in God’s unchanging character and redemptive purposes. True justice cannot be achieved apart from the gospel’s power to transform hearts and minds.

The needs of the world are great, and the opposition often seems greater. But we draw strength from Jesus, who said, “Take heart; I have overcome the world” (John 16:33). In the face of injustice, we choose hope, love and perseverance. And we stand confident that God’s redeeming justice will have the final word. That is the root and the fruit of our faith.

—–

Dr. Christina Crenshaw is an assistant professor at Arizona Christian University, a fellow at the Cultural Research Center and the author of Redeeming Justice. She and her husband live in Texas with their two sons.

Hear More From Dr. Christina Crenshaw on Biblical Justice

What makes biblical justice different from the world’s understanding of fairness? Join Dr. Christina Crenshaw and Roger Marsh as they discuss why compassion and good works must be rooted in the gospel—and how true justice points people to Jesus Christ.

JDFI Guest Blogger

JDFI Guest Blogger

The JDFI Guest Blogger account features articles from guest authors, ministry partners, and other contributors who share insights, personal experiences, and biblical encouragement. These voices bring unique perspectives and practical wisdom to help strengthen families, deepen faith, and navigate life's challenges.

Tags

Recent Posts